• Join AIWW 2021
  • Stay Up to Date
  • Login
Amsterdam International Water Web
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest
    • Agenda
  • Insights
  • About us
    • Who we are
      • About
      • PAC Members
      • AIWW team
    • What We Do
      • What We Do
      • AIWW Activities
      • Amsterdam Agreements Introduction
      • Amsterdam Agreements
  • AIWW2023
    • AIWW2023: Main theme and Subthemes
    • AIWW2023: Programme
    • AIWW2023: Call for Abstracts & Workshops
    • AIWW2023: Scientific Committee
    • AIWW2023: IWA PI2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest
    • Agenda
  • Insights
  • About us
    • Who we are
      • About
      • PAC Members
      • AIWW team
    • What We Do
      • What We Do
      • AIWW Activities
      • Amsterdam Agreements Introduction
      • Amsterdam Agreements
  • AIWW2023
    • AIWW2023: Main theme and Subthemes
    • AIWW2023: Programme
    • AIWW2023: Call for Abstracts & Workshops
    • AIWW2023: Scientific Committee
    • AIWW2023: IWA PI2023
No Result
View All Result
Amsterdam International Water Web
No Result
View All Result
Home Best Practices

Groundwater drainage in New Orleans

Laura Nougues (Deltares) and Roelof Stuurman (Deltares)

September 21, 2022
in Best Practices, Clean Water and Ecosystem Restoration, Featured, Insights, News

Greater New Orleans in Louisiana consists of three parishes: Orleans Parish, Jefferson Parish and St. Bernard Parish. They are almost completely surrounded by water: Lake Pontchartrain to the north, the Mississippi River to the south, Lake Borgne to the east and wetlands to both the east and west. These wet borders and the fact that a large part of New Orleans lies below sea level create major flooding and drainage problems. Due to the bowl-like shape of these parishes, almost all rain that falls in the area, and seepage that rises, can only be drained off with extensive pumping systems or by evaporation. This drainage system, together with the wastewater system and the drinking water network, plays a crucial role in groundwater drainage and recharge.

 

Groundwater and rainwater drainage

New Orleans is equipped with an extensive network of pumping stations (Figure 1) to drain rainwater. The network is designed to drain a maximum of 1 inch (2.5 cm) in the first hour when it rains, followed by 0.5 inch (1.3 cm) per subsequent hour. In total, this pumping system can pump water from the city at a rate of more than 45,000 cubic feet (1,300 m3) per second. However, the pumping stations also drain groundwater, in both wet and dry periods, through the storm drainage system. Due to the age of the storm drainage system and to Hurricane Katrina, this system has been severely damaged. There are many cracks in the pipes and leaks at the pipe connections. Rainwater is drained into catch basins, from where it is transported by gravity through pipes to the nearest drainage pumping station. When it is not raining, smaller “constant duty” pumps remove “dry weather flow” to empty the cisterns of the pumping stations. These constant duty pumps are also turned on when major storms are forecast. They are also burdened by irrigation runoff, domestic runoff from gardens and drained groundwater. In dry periods, the low water level in the pipes and culverts provides groundwater drainage, and in wet periods, the rapid rise in groundwater levels increases the pressure on the rainwater drainage pipes, thereby causing additional groundwater drainage through the storm system.

 

Groundwater, sewage and drinking water network

There is also an interaction between groundwater and other water infrastructures such as the wastewater system and the drinking water network. The wastewater system is a gravity collection system. Throughout the system, there are a number of wastewater pumping stations that lift the wastewater to a higher level for continuous gravity flow to the wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Ideally, the wastewater system should transport only industrial and domestic wastewater and not rainwater or groundwater. However, as mentioned, the system in New Orleans is in poor condition, so the sewage plants receive much more influent than the volume of domestic and industrial wastewater. During wet periods, the wastewater treatment plants treat considerably more water than during dry periods due to the increased groundwater pressure on the wastewater pipes.

The current drinking water network in New Orleans has components that are more than 100 years old and therefore, like the other two systems, suffers from leaking pipes. However, the interaction between groundwater and drinking water network is the opposite of the interaction with the other systems. The leaking pipes cause the drinking water to leak into the ground, causing it to be lost. This water replenishes the groundwater system, after which most of it is drained by the closely situated leaking rainwater and wastewater systems.

In a desk study based on data and information from various parties, the magnitude and consequences of total groundwater drainage and leakage in New Orleans through the stormwater drainage system, the wastewater system and the drinking water system were quantified.

 

Groundwater drainage

To quantify the amount of water drained through the storm drainage system, information from the Sewerage & Water Board of New Orleans (SWBNO) was used. The data were time series for daily precipitation and pump station discharge. An impulse response analysis carried out during the study showed that a significant proportion of the water discharged could not be explained by precipitation. This indicates the presence of drained groundwater in the pump station discharge.

To quantify the amount of drained groundwater in the wastewater system, the total daily WWTP influent (East Bank WWTP, Lower 9th Ward) was collected from SWBNO and a distinction was made between wastewater flow, dry weather groundwater flow (the “base flow”) and wet weather groundwater flow. The base flow was quantified using an existing model developed by Stantec. The wastewater flow and the total drained groundwater were then found using the monitored WWTP influent time series. The influent quantity was found to fluctuate markedly, indicating a strong response of the WWTP influent to precipitation. During wet periods, the water in the wastewater system increases mainly due to additional groundwater pressure on the wastewater pipes.

Monitored groundwater levels from borehole data and groundwater monitoring collected by Deltares, Batture LLC and Tornqvist confirm the influence of the stormwater drainage system and wastewater system on groundwater drainage. After rainfall, the groundwater level drops to a constant level that coincides with the depth of the water infrastructure pipes (Figure 2).

Figure 1: (Above) A diagram of the groundwater behaviour before and after rainfall. After rainfall, we see the groundwater sinking back to the depth of the rainwater drainage system (location Mirabeau, Gentilly New Orleans, data summer 2016).

 

Finally, a water audit by Freeman LLC was used to quantify drinking water losses. The total drinking water loss turns out to consist of two components: the apparent losses and the actual losses. The apparent losses include inaccuracies in customer metering, water theft, illegal connections, data processing problems and billing system errors. The real losses consist of distribution leaks and connection leaks. This study only looked at the real losses, as this is the water that seeps into the ground.

 

Conclusions on the water balance

The following conclusions were drawn from the desk study: 1) the rainwater drainage system accounts for most of the total groundwater drainage (58 per cent); 2) 50 per cent of the influent of the WWTP is groundwater, which is a large unnecessary load for the treatment process; and 3) 55 per cent of the drinking water produced infiltrates the soil during distribution, which means that the drinking water losses are a larger groundwater replenishment than the annual precipitation surplus

Figure 2: The proportions and quantities of the various fluxes in the period 2018-2020 (precipitation 1,782 mm/year and evaporation about 1,289 mm/year).

 

Effects

The huge amount of groundwater that is drained or infiltrated into the soil has major physical and financial implications. Groundwater drainage through the rainwater drainage system and the wastewater system leads to lower groundwater levels. This leads to subsidence through oxidation in peat soils (about 12 per cent of the case study area). In mineral soils such as clay (51 per cent of the case study area), a damaging shrink-swell process occurs whereby the subsoil dries out in dry periods and shrinks and swells again in wet periods. The more the land subsides, the more groundwater has to be drained to prevent groundwater flooding, resulting in further subsidence – a vicious circle.

Since subsidence occurs at different rates depending on soil properties and groundwater conditions, there are many fractures, cracks and sinkholes in roads, car parks and patios, leading to high renovation and repair costs. Another financial consequence concerns drinking water losses. More than half of the drinking water produced is lost during transport.

As mentioned above, 50 per cent of the influent of the WWTP is drained groundwater which does not need to be treated. This places an enormous burden on the wastewater treatment plant, is bad for water quality and costs a lot of money. During big storms, this leads to direct wastewater discharge into the Mississippi River because the WWTP cannot cope with the amount of influent plus drained groundwater.

Repairing these systems is essential to solving all these physical and financial problems, but it is expensive. Not all pipes can be replaced at once. It is important to identify the most critical locations (oldest pipelines or pipelines in areas worst affected by Hurricane Katrina) and to repair them first. Furthermore, additional research is needed before repairs can be started at a location, in order to locally predict the influence of different drainage and recharge fluxes. Restoration of the rainwater drainage system can reduce groundwater drainage, which can lead to groundwater flooding. Or vice versa: the restoration of the drinking water network decreases the groundwater recharge, which may accelerate soil subsidence.

This desk study focused on New Orleans, but groundwater drainage and recharge through faulty pipes is a major problem in many places, in both developed and developing countries. This research demonstrates the value of integrated urban water analysis. Before a groundwater model can be created, it is important to thoroughly study and evaluate the available data to understand what is happening in the field. Only then can a model be created that accurately represents what is happening in reality.

 

Acknowledgements

Thanks to Adam Kay and Tyler Antrup of SWBNO for their data and explanations. And to Bob Mora and Jennifer Snape of Batture LLC for their monitoring well data; they also put us in touch with Sean Walsh of Eustis Engineering LLC. Finally, thanks to Christopher Sanchez from Stantec for his help with the wastewater model and Tor Tornqvist for the Irish Channel groundwater data.

 

Sources

National Resources Conservation Service. (2021). Web Soil Survey. https://websoilsurvey.sc.egov.usda.gov/App/HomePage.htm

Nougues. Laura (2021): Groundwater drainage in New Orleans. An internship (TU Delft) at Deltares

Tags: #groundwaterinfluentmississippiorleanspumping systemswastewater
Share368Tweet230Share64Send
Previous Post

Drinking water treatments and their potential toxicity

Next Post

Image processing for automatic interpretation of drinking water mains inspections

Anniek Corporaal

Anniek Corporaal

Related Posts

What is holding us – YOU – back to take action?
Featured

What is holding us – YOU – back to take action?

September 21, 2023
“Sustainability and an impactful return on investment go well together”
Featured

“Sustainability and an impactful return on investment go well together”

September 21, 2023
Welcome back: Prof. Dr. Christoph Donner
Featured

Welcome back: Prof. Dr. Christoph Donner

September 21, 2023
Join Christopher Gasson in finding solutions for the new concern on the horizon at AIWW2023
Featured

Join Christopher Gasson in finding solutions for the new concern on the horizon at AIWW2023

July 7, 2023
DNA fingerprints show origin and microbiological safety in drinking water production
News

DNA fingerprints show origin and microbiological safety in drinking water production

July 5, 2023
Next Post
Image processing for automatic interpretation of drinking water mains inspections

Image processing for automatic interpretation of drinking water mains inspections

Comments 1

  1. Pingback: Zašto bi inženjering s prirodom mogao spasiti New Orleans i deltu Mekonga - Ensure Blog

AIWW Agenda

AIWW 2023

06-09 November 2023, Amsterdam

Aquatech 2023

06-09 November 2023, Amsterdam

Global Water Agenda

Browse by Category

  • Agri-food (5)
  • AIWW2023 (5)
  • Amsterdam Agreements (7)
  • Best Practices (56)
  • Blue Green Deals with Integrated Solutions (53)
  • Cities (15)
  • Clean Water and Ecosystem Restoration (31)
  • Community engagement and inter-sectoral collaboration (11)
  • Conferentie (16)
  • Featured (117)
  • Future Water Leaders (18)
  • Global Inventory (4)
  • Industries (4)
  • Insights (27)
  • insights-articles (12)
  • News (124)
  • PAC (8)
  • Reuse, Recycle and Recover (19)
  • Risks and Resilience (25)
  • Sponsor (1)
  • Summit (7)
  • Utilies (5)
  • Water Solutions #1. Clean Water and Ecosystem Restoration (15)
  • Water Solutions #2. Reuse, Recycle and Recover (14)
  • Water Solutions #3. Risks and Resilience (16)
  • Water Solutions #4. Community engagement and inter-sectoral collaboration (3)

Browse by Tags

#groundwater AIWW AIWW 2021 AIWW2021 AIWW Conference Amsterdam International Water Web Amsterdam International Water Week clean water conference drinkable rivers drinking water drought EJWP Europe event future water leaders inclusion innovation Insights li an phoa nature recover report resilience reuse risk risk managament risk management sustainable development goals United Nations wastewater wastewater management wastewater treatment water water event water managament water management Water Matters water sector water systems water youth network webinar wetskills working together youth for water

Contact information

Koningskade 40 | 2596 AA | the Hague |
the Netherlands

Phone :
+31 (0) 70 – 32 22 765

Email:
 info@amsterdamiww.com

Latest News

  • What is holding us – YOU – back to take action? September 21, 2023
  • “Sustainability and an impactful return on investment go well together” September 21, 2023
  • Welcome back: Prof. Dr. Christoph Donner September 21, 2023

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Latest Newsletters

  • AIWW2023 – The Drop 💧 Only a few days left to the early-bird discount on tickets to AIWW2023
  • AIWW2023 – The Drop 💧 Only a few days left to the early-bird discount on tickets to AIWW2023 – test (2)
  • AIWW2023 – The Drop 💧 Only a few days left to the early-bird discount on tickets to AIWW2023 – test
  • AIWW2023 – The Drop 💧 Join Christopher Gasson in finding solutions for the new concern on the horizon at AIWW2023
  • AIWW2023 – The Drop 💧 Join Christopher Gasson in finding solutions for the new concern on the horizon at AIWW2023 – test

© 2021 International Water Week       Disclaimer | Privacy Statement

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest
    • Agenda
  • Insights
  • About us
    • Who we are
      • About
      • PAC Members
      • AIWW team
    • What We Do
      • What We Do
      • AIWW Activities
      • Amsterdam Agreements Introduction
      • Amsterdam Agreements
  • AIWW2023
    • AIWW2023: Main theme and Subthemes
    • AIWW2023: Programme
    • AIWW2023: Call for Abstracts & Workshops
    • AIWW2023: Scientific Committee
    • AIWW2023: IWA PI2023

© 2021 International Water Week       Disclaimer | Privacy Statement

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.